One thing society must guard against is discrimination. And one form of discrimination which seems to be snowballing is ageism. Admittedly some old people, if not adaptable to new and positive trends, can end up ruining things or outstaying their welcome. But most of them are gems and more of a balance needs to be struck. We live in a consumer culture of use and discard, where the general mindset is: what’s useful today cannot surely be relevant tomorrow. And although the Roman empire has long collapsed, the mob still bays for the blood of fallen heroes. Nowhere is this more apparent than in football, the quintessence of popular culture and eternal metaphor of life.
Last week history was made when Tottenham Hotspur finally beat Arsenal away after seventeen years. It was a historic victory and one which proved the value of older players. Arsenal did not have one player on the pitch over thirty years old, yet the player named man of the match was Tottenham’s William Gallas, a 33 year old French defender who was discarded by Arsenal before this season even started. To add salt to the wound of Arsenal’s defeat, Gallas was also made captain by Spurs coach Harry Redknapp before the game. After Tottenham’s incredible win a number of younger Spurs players like Jenas and Kaboul stressed the importance of having Gallas in the side, whose leadership qualities helped Spurs to turn their two nil deficit into a 3-2 win.
This is not to say that Arsenal coach Arsene Wenger got his just desserts for ditching Gallas. The latter is known to be a vocal character and his public outbursts at Arsenal could not have been helping Wenger’s plans. Yet although youth must have its fling, it is hard to win big matches with kids alone. Ferguson is constantly heralded as being the guy who ‘won it with the kids’ in the 95-96 season when Beckham, Giggs, Scholes etc. burst onto the scene. Yet many forget that that side was also studded with grizzled senior players like Steve Bruce, Gary Pallister, David May and Denis Irwin. Wenger seems reluctant to pay large fees to keep hold of senior players, yet although he is to be admired for the youngsters he unearths and bloods, the Arsenal coach must be fast realising that experience and maturity also possess market value.
It certainly cannot be excluded that wily old fox Wenger will mastermind a turnaround but, technically gifted as his latest Gunners side is, there seems to be something lacking with his squad. And it’s not technique or potential. We’re talking wise ol’ heads. That’s right, the over 30s veteran that barks at the boys to get stuck in, who can read the way the game is going and lead by example when putting in a few ‘Chopper Harris’ tackles or engaging in some dirty old Billy Bremner gamesmanship. All this is crucial to a winning side. An idealist is one who thinks roses make better soup than cabbages because they smell better and it appears Wenger is falling into this trap. He should recall that his Invincibles record-breaking side that ran away with the Prem in 03/04 featured veterans like Martin Keown, Sol Campbell and Ray Parlour.
Every team needs a balance of veterans and young starlets. Just ask great Scot Sir Alex Ferguson, who still unleashes his trusted pint-sized ginger ninja Paul Scholes to rip heads off opponents when things get sticky. He’s a piece of work that Scholes, at times putting his former midfield mate Keano to shame, and if he were thrown into a fridge with a rabid lioness, I’m not sure what bets I’d place on the feline surviving. Which is not to mention the value of the evergreen Ryan Giggs, albeit a balder and gaunter prospect than the fresh-faced pin-up boy of yore, but still a seasoned trickster along the wing or nipping in behind the striker. And there can be little doubt that if Beckham had followed the Ferguson code of shunning the limelight, he would still be gracing the right wing at Manchester United.
Which is not to mention some of Beckham’s Italian contemporaries, two of whom ruled Juventus in the days when Becks fuelled Manchester United’s forays into the European Champions League. Indeed at 36 Alex Del Piero is still an integral part of Juventus, even scoring a brilliant winner against deadly rivals AC Milan this season. Which is not to mention Del Piero’s former team-mate Filippo Inzaghi with whom Del Piero formed such a successful and unlikely little and little (meant to be little and large) striking partnership at Juve before Inzaghi moved to AC Milan, where this season he broke Gerd Mueller’s record in the European Champions League and would probably be extending it had injury not cut him short. Despite this latest setback there can be little doubt that Superpippo will be back next year to continue his goalscoring exploits, although he would by then be 38.
The duo's exploits might have also stirred their former Juventus team-mate Edgar Davids, at 37, to come out of retirement this year. He was certainly deemed fit enough to be offered a stint at Championship side Crystal Palace. Although he went on to quit early, It appears his attitude with his new team mates had more to do with his stint coming to an end than did his lack of playing ability. As useful as a senior player may be on the field of play, you certainly cannot teach an old dog new tricks!
Ageing beautifully also appears to be in evidence on the West Coast of Australia, with 35 year old Robbie Fowler rolling back the years with his hat-trick against Melbourne Victory, his 2nd and 3rd goals proving that his left foot finishing remains world class. His goals brought back memories of his infamous hat-trick against Arsenal which remains the fastest ever hat-trick in the English Premier League.
Indeed certain goal-poaching instincts and skills simply cannot be coached. But older heads also serve to put the boot in when it matters at crucial points of the game, thereby helping to drag their team-mates along. It’s probably why Capello tried to reintroduce Scholes and Carragher to his side before world cup 2010 shortly after news of Beckham’s injury made world headlines.
Old heads also lead by example and drag their team-mates along when it matters most. Its probably why Inter Milan keep Javier Zanetti (37) on their books and refuse to let go of Materazzi (37), and why Serie A leaders AC Milan have no concerns with keeping 34 year olds Oddo, Yepes and Seedorf (often nicknamed Slowdorf) in their squad and would probably still have Maldini on their books if the latter hadn’t decided to retire at age 41.
This has been a season of indisposable heroes. Aston Villa supporters might scratch their heads about 37 year old Robert Pires having recently joined their squad but the Frenchman might yet prove an inspired acquisition if he lives up to Houllier’s former shrewd acquisition of Scottish midfielder Gary McAllister in 2000, who at 35 spurred Liverpool on to 3 trophies in one season during his solitary year there, a trophy haul which since remains unmatched by an English club.
All of which makes me think that when a player gets older he actually gets better and better. The only thing he may start to lack is the belief of fans what with the media constantly chipping away at older players’ confidence by claiming they are too old and making them scapegoats for team losses. All players certainly have dips in form, but so too have young players. Is Rooney finished? He would be if he were over 30, with just about every tabloid journalist probably lining up to call on him to call time on his career. It’s a grossly unfair trend among many club fans and media outlets to pick on an older player which is why criticism of older players often goes ignored by coaches who in fact prefer experienced players.
Why shouldn’t players last longer with the advanced training regimes and specialised diets afforded them in this day and age? Back in the pre-war and post-war days many players played until and beyond their fifties which certainly could not have been a mean task given the little protection they were afforded by referees back then.
England legend Stanley Matthews played beyond his sixties, and Pele (arguably the world’s greatest goalscorer) retired at 37. And what about the shameless 37 year old former Socceroo Kevin Muscat, who years after making international headlines for his shocking challenge on Frenchman Christophe Dugarry, still captains the Melbourne Victory, having twice led them to the A League title after choosing to snap shins in midfield instead of defence. Muscat certainly the most famous player of Maltese background, still showing all players how far they can go if they possess enough gall.
At times managers latch onto fans' complaints that players are getting too old and claim that they’re ‘building for the future’ but often its just an excuse to justify their losses because they’re ‘blooding young players’. Which is probably why Bolton’s Kevin Davies wasn’t selected again for England after becoming the oldest England debutant since Leslie Crompton in 1950 when he was selected to play a Euro 2012 qualifier against Montenegro last month. Yet despite his advanced years (33) many fans have long argued that Davies should be an England regular what with his cast-iron pie arse being a useful tool with which to hold up the ball for a younger nippier striker.
Older players might at worst lose a yard of pace, but experience counts for so much more, as was evidenced by Teddy Sheringham before he hung up his boots. Here was a striker who lasted so long because he could read the game so well. It’s easy to discard older players but they’re difficult to replace. As evidenced in the Spurs-Arsenal clash, they are all too often a determining factor in close encounters, just like when Spain faced the awesome young Germany side in the semis of World Cup 2010 and old head Puyol (second oldest player on the pitch after fellow Spaniard Capdevila) popped up to bang in the winner with his shaggy head in what was a tense and close encounter.
Conventional wisdom has usually dictated that retirement ages should be 34 max for a striker, 36 for a midfielder, 38 for a defender and 40 for a goalie, but this season the exploits of many veterans have flown into the face of this dogma. David James has broken the 40 year old mark playing in goal for Bristol and will he play on till 50? One wonders what hairstyle or woeful cream suit will he might sport at that age? Perhaps James is hoping to follow in the footsteps of the other eccentric keeper and inventor of the infamous ‘scorpion kick’, Colombian goalie Rene Higuita, who only retired earlier this year at the venerable age of 43.
For all the debate surrounding whether older players should be kept in club sides and international squads, I say let them play for as long as they want to, it’s often the media hype about how old they are that eventually gets them to pack it all in. Tell a football player – or anyone for that matter – that they’re finished for long enough and they’ll even start to believe it. But once they’re gone, they're inevitably always missed.